The Corporate Veil (or How to Lose Your Business, but Keep Your House)
Allan BranchThis post is a guest post from Allan Branch, a one time freelancer who created LessAccounting for freelancers who need to keep track of money or send invoices.
What if someone could sue your company and then, since your company has no money, take your house or win a judgment that takes you fifteen years to pay? The Corporate Veil provides protection against this happening to you.
What is it?
The Corporate Veil is the legal shield that protects an individual from being personally liable for the actions of his/her company. This only applies to owners, partners, board members, not employees or share holders. In this country a person, or a company may sue any other person or company for anything, at any time. But there is only one reason to sue, and that is to be awarded money. So if a person or company doesn’t have any money, then there isn’t really anything to sue for.
Unless of course, if there is no corporate veil, then they can come after you personally. This could leave you financially ruined for the rest of your life.
How does it work?
There are six types of companies in the US: Sole Proprietor, Partnership, Limited Liability Corporation (LLC), Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), Corporation (C-Corp), and Corporation (S-Corp). Of this list, Sole Proprietor and Partnership DO NOT protect the owner/partner, the others do.
Does this apply to me?
Are you a freelancer? Do you own your own business? Have you done any work for which you received a 1099? Have you done any work for a friend that you were paid for, but aren’t going to report as income (yes, building a website for $2000 counts)? If you answered yes to any of these questions, then congratulations, you are a business.
That’s right, you are a business even without filing a fictitious name statement, buying a business license, creating a corporate entity, or paying taxes. Any individual who does work and is paid for this work is considered a Sole Proprietorship, if two or more people do work together and are paid for it are considered a Partnership.
Who’s rule is this? The IRS. And the courts. The point here is that if you are doing any kind of work for pay you must protect your self and your family by creating a corporate shield. Small businesses are more often targets for veil piercing, you never hear about someone trying to pierce Apple’s veil and take Steve Job’s house.
How you can protect yourself.
Protecting yourself and your partners is very easy. The first thing to do is to create some sort of corporate entity to shield yourself. Any of the other four company types listed above, offer the same liability protection. (Although they each offer different tax benefits, so consult an accountant before choosing.)
Now you are protected. You still have to be careful, you must do certain things or else your plaintiff (or the IRS) can “pierce the corporate veil” and take your house. You have to sign every document with your title alongside your name, E.G. Steven A Bristol, President, Less Everything. Inc. You have to use a separate bank account for the business. You must never mix your personal finances with your corporate finance, E.G. write a payroll check for yourself, don’t just use the ATM, and don’t buy your daughter’s Christmas gifts with the company American Express card. In short, you must act as though you and your business are separate entities. If you are in doubt about anything, ask your accountant.
You can read more about piercing the corporate veil at Wikipedia.




















Mark H. Abucayon
January 27th, 2008
Nice post, very informative one. Thanks
linda
January 27th, 2008
Good post.
Any advice for Australian freelancers, or does this not apply to us? Because I do all that stuff in the last paragraph. Whoops!
Brett McKay
January 27th, 2008
What kind of transactions could a freelancer get involved in where someone would go after their house?
James
January 27th, 2008
Great post!
Any info available for UK freelancers - I’d imagine similar rules apply etc. but it would be nice to know where I stand… Plus - At what age are you fully liable for your actions etc??
contentgrrl
January 27th, 2008
Ah, the payroll check. I was wondering how I would manage to move money from my business account to my personal one. Now the question is, do I pay taxes as an employer if it’s just me, or do I do a 1099? Hmmm. I’m guessing the advice will be to contact an accountant.
Another question: How often is a freelance writer, designer, or developer sued?
Well, I found one story, very well written, about investors of bankrupt Lingua Franca magazine going after payments to freelancers in the unusual last months of publication:
http://www.mediabistro.com/articles/cache/a1158.asp
And here another story about employment agency JL Kirk & Associates going after a Nashville blogger who disagreed with their practices and blogged about them.
http://saucygrrl.wordpress.com/2007/04/12/pay-up-shut-up-or-get-sued/
It’s enough to take precautions.
MikiP
January 27th, 2008
For example making sites using non original software, or using graphics and images protected with copyright. At least I guess
Andy
January 27th, 2008
@Brett: I sometimes write automation software for manufacturing customers. I’ve been in situations where, if something went wrong with the code, something would explode and possibly kill people in the general vicinity. Serious liability issues. Without the corporate entity around my work, I could lose everything I have now and into the future.
Allan, good intro post for why you need a real company around you. Many freelancers will claim that any good lawyer can pierce the veil, but I think that’s just wrong info. The best advice is to always run your freelancing business like a real business and not like an extension of your personal life and keep a good accountant and lawyer in your contacts list so you can quickly get assistance if you’re not sure you’re doing something right. Think of it like insurance: you hope you never need it, but you better pay the premiums to ensure that when you do need it, that it’s there for you.
CatherineL
January 27th, 2008
Hi there - I chose one of these for my new business to limit my risk a little and also to pay less tax than I did as a sole trader.
You do still need to tread carefully though. If you’re taking out a business loan and you’re a fairly new company, the bank may still want to secure the loan against your home. So you could still lose it if things went wrong.
I would advise anyone from the uk to check out the Tax Cafe guides before deciding upon setting up a Limited Company, as it isn’t worthwhile taxwise until you’re making a certain amount of profit.
Jon
January 27th, 2008
Nice post. It’s not hard to go about forming a real company, it’s just daunting. When I was thinking about getting an LLC, I was looking at using legalzoom.com, they’ve been around for a while and I’ve seen commercials for them too, so I tend to think they’re somewhat legitimate.
MattT
January 27th, 2008
@Jon You don’t need to use a service like legalzoom.com. Creating an LLC is a relatively easy process. Start at the website of your state government. Most will have the information and forms you need, and doing it yourself will be a lot cheaper.
Andy
January 27th, 2008
@Jon: if you want to form an LLC, you may not need to pay someone else anymore to draw up the papers. Many states offer online forms to let you create your entity in as little as a few minutes (I set up an LLC in about 15 minutes from a hotel room using Georgia’s online form). What you’re looking for is going to be called something like the Corporations Division within your Secretary of State’s office. Just contact the SecState where you live and they’ll be happy to direct you to where you need to fill out the proper forms. In Georgia, the cost was about $100 and they had a link to the IRS site to create a Federal Employment ID Number and with both of those, I could go open a bank account and start operating my LLC.
Adrian
January 27th, 2008
Just what I was looking for, thanks for the informative writeup.
Marco Castro
January 28th, 2008
I am a freelancer based out of Miami, FL.
Here is a question…
When it comes to taxes i am a bit confused. Should i be charging my clients tax on projects? Or not?
If not, how do i know what percentage is income and what percentage will be applied to Uncle Sam?
Anyone i US managing this? your input will be appreciated.
_M
Andy
January 28th, 2008
@Marco: contact the Florida Department of Revenue and ask them whether they require you to collect state sales tax for the services/products you offer and whether that’s just for clients within Florida or whether it would also apply to clients outside of Florida or even outside the USA. They should provide that information without needing information about you or your business. If they do, register for a state sales tax number and start collecting sales tax. As to your question about the IRS: your best bet is to go find a good small business accountant, but expect you’ll spend about 30% of your income on income taxes.
@Contentgrrl: yes, with payroll comes employer taxes. However, without payroll, you’d still end up paying most of those taxes anyway. The only taxes an employer usually pays is 1/2 of Social Security and state/federal unemployment taxes. Self-employed people end up paying both halves of Social Security taxes anyway, so you can’t escape it anyway. However, with payroll and something like an S-Corporation, you can pay yourself a reasonable salary (say, $50K) and take any additional money as dividend distributions (which are not taxed for social security purposes). Yes, your best bet is to find a good small business accountant. As for your other question: the little guy gets sued or threatened with suits more often than anyone will care to admit. I’ve never been sued over my consulting gigs, but there’s always a first time and the outcome can be quite awful if you don’t have your company structure properly implemented.
And you guys should go over and join the forums on the site, because many of these questions have already been answered there.
TLM
January 29th, 2008
This is a very good post. In order to become a sound business person you must learn how to protect yourself. One question, do many freelancers work by contract or is everything viewed as work for hire by inquiring parties? FYI, LLC stands for Limited Liability Company.
thefrosty
August 11th, 2008
i hope I would never take a job that I screwed myself into loosing my house. Cause I dont have one..
But I did just win a court case the oposite, i sued a client that wouldn’t pay, and I won! Now I just have to wait for payment.